The Tragic, Beautiful True Story Behind Peter Dinklages My Dinner with Hervé

In 1993, Sacha Gervasi was working as a journalist in London when he received what would become the strangest—and most meaningful—assignment of his life: an interview with Hervé Villechaize. Gervasi was supposed to crank out a 500-word “Where Are They Now?”–style blurb about the French actor, perhaps best known for playing evil henchman Nick Nack in 1974s The Man with the Golden Gun. But it had been about a decade since Villechaize was fired from his last high-profile job—the TV series Fantasy Island, where he played sidekick Tattoo—after demanding equal pay to his co-star, Ricardo Montalbán. And aside from the occasional Geraldo appearance or odd Dunkin Donuts commercial, Villechaizes career had dried up.

Gervasi did not expect much from the interview.

The reporter dutifully flew to Los Angeles, and met Villechaize for what was supposed to be a quick conversation at a West Hollywood restaurant. Gervasi ran through his questions and collected a few quotes, before packing up his recorder and notebook—eager to get to a more exciting interview on his itinerary. But Villechaize was not finished talking.

“I had seen some rapid movement [out of the corner of my eye],” remembered Gervasi during a conversation about My Dinner with Hervé, a touching tribute to his misunderstood interview subject starring Peter Dinklage as Villechaize and Jamie Dornan as Gervasis proxy. The film, written and directed by Gervasi, premieres October 20—twenty-five years after Gervasi was rushing to leave that fateful interview.

When Gervasi turned around, having packed his bag, “Hervé was standing there pointing a lock knife at my throat. He said, Listen, youve written the story before you got here. You just wanted Tattoo stories and Man with the Golden Gun stories. So Ive told you all the bullshit. Do you want to hear the real story of my life?”

Gervasi had not given Villechaizes story much thought. But, recalled Gervasi, “There was something about the look in his eye which was so intriguing and compelling and strange. When he pulled the knife, obviously it was a sort of coup de théâtre—about getting my attention. It was about puncturing this sort of bubble of judgment that I had walked in with. . . . To suddenly be presented with this living and breathing human being who was just fully aware of his being stereotyped by the press as a punch line was quite something.”

Intrigued, Gervasi ended up meeting the actor three times in a five-day span, and hearing his tragic life story. Villechaizes father had been a doctor in Paris. Upon discovering that his son suffered from proportionate dwarfism, he took Hervé to medical clinics in Minnesota, England, and Germany in hopes of curing the condition. At a young age, Villechaize was subjected to barbaric treatments including having sheeps marrow injected into his spine. He did not grow taller than 3-foot-10; Villechaize was bullied mercilessly.

“There was an almost medieval intolerance for people who were different at that time,” said Gervasi of Villechaizes coming-of-age years in 1950s France. “His brother, Patrick, told me that [Hervé] would walk down the street and just be kicked in the head for being different.” After a promising start as a painter—he became the youngest artist to have his work shown in the Museum of Paris—Villechaize changed course at his fathers suggestion.

“His father said, Go where the freaks go. Go to New York,” explained Gervasi. “So he was sent there and became a part of that burgeoning avant-garde sort of Greenwich Village theater culture. He became a character. He would wear a poncho and smoke cigarillos—and based his new persona on the Man with No Name, having learned English watching Steve McQueen and Clint Eastwood and John Wayne on TV. As he was telling me this story, I was thinking. My god, theres so much more to him than this punch line of [his Fantasy Island characters tag line] Da plane! Da plane! . . . He is a tremendously complex, contradictory, brave, crazy, hilarious, wonderful, dangerous person. He was the most original person I think Id ever met, so I promised him that I would one day tell his story.”

Gervasi returned to London with 12 hours worth of cassette tapes from his time with Villechaize. About a week later—on Sunday, September 4, 1993, at around 5:36 P.M.—the phone in Gervasis Clapham flat rang.

“It was Kathy Self, who was Hervés real-life girlfriend. She called to say that Hervé had committed suicide just a few hours before,” said Gervasi. “I spontaneously got incredibly emotional. I started listening back to the tapes and I realized that he knew he was going to do it. For some random reason, he just grabbed onto whatever journalist passed by and poured his guts out to me in literally the final week of his life. Hed entrusted me with his story and, in effect, I was his suicide note.”

Taking his promise seriously, Gervasi wrote a piece that he felt properly honored Villechaize—a complex human whom Hollywood essentially dismissed as a punch line or sight gag. When the paper watered down his draft, Gervasi decided to tell Villechaizes story in another medium—and wrote his first script, a 34-page screenplay about his evening with the actor.

Because of the subject matter, the screenplay wasnt exactly rushed into production. “One particular studio said, Look, I want to save you a lot of time: you could not come up with a more uncommercial concept. The suicidal-dwarf movie with elaborate sort of time jumps. Its never gonna happen. There is nothing that will ever justify the money to make this the way you want to make it.” But after he attended U.C.L.A. film school, the script did lead to a meeting with Steven Spielberg, who hired Gervasi to write The Terminal.

After seeing Peter Dinklage in The Station Agent and onstage in Richard III, Gervasi became convinced that “Peter was the only actor who could play the part of Hervé.” After Gervais shared his story with Dinklage about 15 years ago, the actor agreed to star—and My Dinner with Hervé became their joint passion project. A few years ago, the duo was finally about to give up on getting My Dinner with Hervé made. But Dinklages Game of Thrones stardom ended up being the currency they needed, and HBO agreed to make the movie.

The filmmaking process was strange for Gervasi—who insisted on filming the final scenes inside the Universal Sheraton, the actual hotel where Gervasi and Villechaize had their last meeting.

“You can imagine how surreal it was to be sitting on the steps in the actual place where the meeting with Hervé had happened,” said Gervasi. “Im looking at my two actors, one portraying a version of me and Peter Dinklage playing Hervé, exactly where it happened.” Though the film is slightly dramatized—Dinklage and Dornans characters spend one raucous evening together instead of three meetings—Gervasi insists that the final 20 or 30 minutes of the film, including the goodbye between reporter and interview subject, play out just as they did in real life.

“He tugged at my sleeve and he pulled me down so that our faces were side by side,” recalled Gervasi. “He looked me in the eye. He had such pain and defiance with tears in his eyes and he said, Tell them, I regret nothing.”

And in My Dinner with Hervé, Gervasi conveys that exact message.

“I was trying to honor the meeting I had had with him, and how we all kind of walk into a situation with a certain kind of judgment,” said Gervasi. “But once you peel all the layers away, you get to a bit more of what the real truth is underneath.” He still sounded a bit surprised that he was actually able to get the movie made. “Finally, I feel like Ive dispatched my sort of duty to that promise, and Ive told the story the way it was meant to be told.”

Get Vanity Fairs HWD NewsletterSign up for essential industry and award news from Hollywood.

Victor Garber

Youre a hopeful kid on Christmas morning . . . no pony.

Youre a Park Avenue dandy, flush with inherited money, saying a cheery hello to all the neighborhood doormen, delighted to think what a decent, fair-minded chap you are.

Youre a Holocaust survivor visiting your wifes grave, seeing that her tombstone and many others are broken and spray-painted with swastikas.

Youre an old man screaming at the kids to get off your lawn . . . except that there are no kids, and no lawn.

Robin Wright

Your slob husband has just walked out the door, leaving his stained underwear, muddy boots, and newspapers on the floor one damn time too many, and youre screaming at him from the bedroom window as you throw his entire wardrobe onto the front yard.

You got married at 16, divorced at 20—three children and no idea where your ex has gone, three months overdue on your rent, wondering whatever happened to the romantic vision of the future you had as a girl.

Youre with two friends who were at college with you, talking about the basketball star you all dated in school.

Youve been the executive assistant for the same man for 15 years—and sleeping with him for almost as long—hearing him fire you and knowing that you have enough evidence to make you rich.

Pierce Brosnan

Youre the director of a new Broadway play in rehearsals, telling your arrogant, lazy but famous diva that if she keeps coming late and doesnt stop drinking at lunch, youll give the part to her understudy . . . knowing that if you do, the show wont go on.

Youre an innocent man hearing a jury foreman declare you guilty of setting a fire that killed your wife and child.

Youre a presidential candidate at a meet-and-greet, shaking hands with a millionaire you know is bankrolling your opponent; you hate his guts, but you dont dare alienate him.

Youre an up-and-coming shoe designer, seeing the first model in your first runway show slip and fall in her $2,000 stilettos.

Taraji Henson

Youre a young, married woman whose husband has just admitted he feels absolutely no sexual attraction to you, that the marriage was a huge mistake.

Youre home from work early, walking into your husbands home office and seeing him nude, watching Judge Judy.

Youre the mother of a teenage son, embarrassing him in front of his friends by demonstrating how you and your friends danced in the disco age.

Youre a repressed, middle-aged woman suddenly losing your inhibitions at a male strip club.

Kathleen Turner

Youre a woman in a crosswalk with your slow-moving toddler grandchild, looking up to see two skateboarders bearing down on you, laughing and talking and wearing earphones.

Youre a respected and tough music critic, who, at the urging of a friend, reluctantly goes to hear an unknown string ensemble in a small, old church with beautiful, resonating sound and are suddenly and surprisingly moved to tears over a late Beethoven quartet.

Youre a cranky, old lady at the supermarket in your electric wheelchair, screaming at people to get out of your way: “Cant you see Im disabled!”

Youre a stage mother in training, at your 12-year-old sons class play, desperately mouthing the line that he has forgotten.

Blair Underwood

Youre a gangbanger attending the murder trial of your brother, making eye contact with a witness as she walks toward the stand.

Youre a college-football coach with a losing record and restless alumni, three points behind in a crucial game, watching the clock run down at what seems like warp speed.

Youre a distraught lover trying to stop your girlfriend from driving away after an angry breakup, screaming as she slams the door on your hand.

Youre waiting at a boat ramp to pick up your wife and daughter after a white-water trip when you see their empty raft float by.

Michael C. Hall

Youre a new boyfriend, at home with your girlfriends six-year-old son for the first time, telling the kid, “I dont care how young you are, or what you fucking think you need . . . When your mother gets home you can whine all you want, but until then, get the fuck out of my face!”

Youre a high-school basketball player, secretly proud of your flagrant fouls, pleading with the ref that slamming the point guard of the opposing team to the floor was completely accidental.

Youre an assembly-line worker being fired for fighting with co-workers, telling your boss that youll see him again, real soon.

Youre a mid-level trader for Goldman, frazzled by trying to keep up with instantaneous micro-transactions, realizing—just seconds too late—that youve made a potentially disastrous move.

PreviousNext